Rethinking Business Management is
dedicated to the past and present deans, faculty, staff, alumni, and
students of IESE Business School on the occasion of its 50th
anniversary. This book has as its origins an initiative that began
back in 2005. With IESEs 50th birthday on the horizon, it seemed an
appropriate moment to embark on a long-term process of reassessing
the state of business management education in light of new
developments. The initiative came from the Social Trends Institute
(STI), a nonpartisan, inter-national research center based in New
York City. STI drew up and submitted a proposal on the matter to
its organizational partner and friend, the Witherspoon Institute,
whose leaders, Stephen Whelan and Luis Tellez, accepted.
Let me explain the reasons behind this initiative. So much is
happening in our modern world that has a bearing on business
management. Certain aspects of business are changing much faster
than ever before, while business management has a tough time keeping
up, let alone leading the way. Still, amidst all of this change,
some values, principles, and practices remain the same, or at least
should remain the same, no matter what innovations come along
tomorrow or the day after. We could refer to them as business
management principles, or even business management foundations. And
they are unshakeable because they correspond to universal human
nature, to the very essence of human beings.
Because this is the case, business management must never lose sight
of the fact that it is, first and foremost, a human enterprise,
composed of and for people. Subscribing to this philosophy, IESE
printed in its debut brochure fifty years ago that business
organizations are worth what their people are worth. In short,
business management is about people, a simple truth made complicated
by changes in peoples environments.
Consider just a few examples of realities that a business manager
of, say, only fifteen years ago did not face but which fill the
pages of today's financial newspapers: the accelerating pace of
globalization, new global capital influxes, the spate of corporate
scandals, the incredible rise of Chinese and Indian markets, a
current fifteen-year run of world economic prosperity (a feat never
before accomplished), and the subprime financial crisis.
Undoubtedly, these and countless other recent events have impacted
peoples values and expectations in business, and it should be the
duty of educators to observe and analyze the ways in which this has
occurred, whether for better or worse. And finally, taking all of
this into account, scholars and educators should develop a model of
business management suitable for current times, yet loyal to the
timeless code of moral conduct as accepted by both Aristotle,
Judeo-Christians, and many of the world's other major religious
traditions. So while the business manager of fifteen years ago
inhabited a different world than the business manager of today, the
two can still share a common sense of purpose and of right and
wrong, elements that place them within the same larger story of
business management.
It is therefore pertinent to ask whether modern business education
has successfully tied together the discoveries of the present with
the wisdom of the past, the ephemeral and the permanent. In many
cases, unfortunately, the answer is no. Confusion concerning
identity and purpose, and a tension between the short lifespan of
popular theories and a desire for more stable concepts (as is true
in many sciences), characterize much of modern business education.
Clearly, rewinding the clock is not a viable solution, but neither
can business schools afford to go forward without a meta-narrative
of identity and purpose, and become, by default, mercenary in their
approach. Rethinking Business Management could be described as an
attempt to help illuminate just such a narrative in business
management, one that both recognizes the new paradigms in business
and retains a sense of purpose articulated within a moral framework
and reaching above and beyond mere profit and loss. It must be a
narrative that sees an ever-present ethical dimension in each and
every business decision. Recent experiences continue to remind
educators that the answers to the questions What is business for?
and What is the business school for? require an ethical
vocabulary, such as we hope can be found in this book.
I would like to thank the contributors to this book. Their
reflections and discussion play an important role in our long-term
project of revisiting the foundations of business management. In
this effort, we are always inspired by the conviction that business
management should recognize the immutable aspects of human nature,
those present across all eras and cultures. Despite pronouncements
about the so-called economic man, human beings behavior and
aspirations should not be understood in purely economic terms.
Business management has the potential to be so much grander by
helping satisfy the human penchant for values and goodness that
cannot be expressed in numbers or explained by utilitarian logic.
Indeed, the future belongs to those who are rethinking business
management accordingly.
Carlos Cavall
President
Social Trends
Institute